2010 December » New York State Youth Leadership Council

Monthly Archive: December 2010

The Problem

“Herein lie words” of an uncompleted movement and unresolved struggle, “that if
read with patience,” yet due diligence, shed light on the present condition of two million
undocumented youth – so called DREAMers1
– that today demand most earnestly and doggedly
to be fully recognized as human beings (Du Bois: “The Forethought”).

To become an undocumented immigrant requires very little but is a result of
tremendous social, economic, political and environmental forces; I offer my story as example:
My family had been farmers for millennia – ever since first setting foot on this continent. We
had settled in a small village (San Miguel Ahuhuititlan) located in the rugged southern state
of Oaxaca where the Sierra Madre Sur and Sierra Madre Oaxaca – the unconnected southern
spine of the Rocky Mountains – unite. The place, until recently, spoke mainly mixteco – the
native dialect – and possessed little in roads, potable water, and houses with more than a dirt
floor – save for the Catholic Church at the center of town. The church and the villager’s last
names – for only those that fled to higher uplands were able to keep their native family names
- are vestiges of Spanish colonization. My ancestors remained in that village through the fall of
the Spanish Empire and Mexico’s first hundred years as a sovereign nation.

What finally made us flee north was the start of a new era – unfair and unbalanced
neoliberal trade agreements between Mexico and its richer neighbors destroyed our ability
to sustain ourselves. Our market – we were told – had become global, and, after a period of
transition, would eventually ensure a more vital nation and people – where wealth trickled
down to fulfill the needs of all classes. Needless to say, such wealth never came and, moreover,
the hunger, debt, and suffering of the nation increased.

I was born on a cold January day, on the dirt floor of my grandmother’s house, where
only nana was present to aid my mother in the delivery. Lacking any soap with which to wash
me, my mother laid me on her to avoid the ants which would’ve been attracted to our blood.
Two years later my parents would leave for America, leaving me and my older sister of four
behind to be under care of our maternal grandparents. A year of separation proved too much
and eventually my parents thought it best to have their family here in America with some hope
of an education and decent living rather than in Mexico where life was increasingly scarce and
the outlook grim.

NAFTA and other trade agreements provided and continue to allow free flow of goods
and capital across borders; unfortunately my family’s attempt to seek a livelihood which was
no longer feasible in their home nation was deemed an unlawful act2. I, at the age of three,
knew nothing of my actions or their repercussions, and today at the age of twenty am no longer
ashamed of all past experiences that brought my family and me to this place in time.

However, my story is not unique. In fact, two million narratives share the same plot
under similar circumstances. Stories of economic displacement, political asylum, and spiritual
refuge are particular to the souls trapped in similar predicaments. What these sojourners have
begun to organize around is the DREAM Act – a proposal that would provide temporary legal
residence of undocumented youth who came to this nation as minors, have resided in America
for five continuous years, possess good moral character with no criminal record and have
graduated from high school or the equivalent. Having met these initial requirements, recipients
would have six years of temporary legal status to complete two years of military service or
college to earn permanent legal residence (National Immigration Law Center, 2010: Dream Act).

Nearly a decade has passed since the bill was initially proposed, without much success.
The students continue to grow in number and strength, yet they prove to be of little or no
match to the cowardice and fear hovering in Washington. Years of bickering and blaming have
yielded little to no relief while students struggle to continue their education to ultimately be
denied legal work and have the “doors of opportunity” shut in their face (Du Bois, 1903: 3).

What these students ask might pique the curiosity of intellectuals, critics, and the
opposition alike. What is an American? Who sets the standards? Can our definition of America
change? – Shift? Who decided who gets to participate in democracy? Who is represented
in the legislature? What views or priorities shape the discourse of our nation? How does a
personal narrative become political? What does it mean to live in the most powerful nation at
the start of the twenty-first century with little to no rights to claim.

This present plight is of most concern to you and me, oh “gentle reader,” for the tragedy
of these young folks is a tragedy of our age, holding ransom our collective humanity (Du Bois,
1903:1). Lastly, it is worth repeating that you, I, and them – we – are all “bone of the bone
and flesh of the flesh” of the same human body and that our communal subsistence depends
on whole and unequivocal justice (Genesis 2:23). Now that I have laid down before you the
foundation of our current crisis let us delve deeper into the pain and beauty which two million
of our brothers and sisters experience each and every day.


1.There is an estimated 2.1 million undocumented youth population that could benefit from the DREAM Act -
Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act (Migration Policy Institute, 2010:1).
2. Mexico is currently one of the most accepting nations of neoliberal trade agreements (Villareal, 2010: Summary).

COME THROUGH our YLC HOLIDAY POTLUCK PARTY – Tomorrow Dec 30th

YOU ARE INVITED!

YLC Holiday Potluck Party
on Thursday, December 30th @ 7pm
WHERE: YLC office located on 220 5th Avenue 26th Street 5th Floor, New York NY
Come celebrate with us the end of the year and the holidays.
This is the time to thank you for your support and involvement with us; as it is also the time to get ready for an even stronger 2011!
Be ready to participate in our YLC Brown Elephant Gift Exchange, our fun spin on a gift exchange.
Bring a GENTLY USED or NEW ITEM that costs no more than $15
Be creative!
Remember to bring a snack, drink or plate to share
Email info@nysylc.org to tell us what you are bringing
**SEE YOU THERE and BRING A FRIEND :) **

41 reasons

My name is Neidy Ortiz and I’m a 21 year old Dreamer. My father brought me to this country when I was 13yrs old and was here where I finished my middle school and high-school. I was always an excellent student, honor roll and medals were part of those years. When I was in high-school I was accepted to a business academy within the school where I won 2nd place in a huge competition of business students for my school. Those are my most memorable memories from school. I graduated from high-school in ’08, and since then I haven’t seen the inside of a classroom. I wanted and still want to study international business and exterior commerce but as an “illegal immigrant” I didn’t have access to any kind of help from the government, loans, financial aid, etc. I’ve been working since I was 14, and haven’t been back to my country or seen my family and my mom since then. My life right now is a little complicated and the Dream Act was my last hope. You guys did an amazing job! I’m really considering the idea of going back to Colombia for good since I can’t come back anyways. I want to study and achieve the goals that were once set on my mind. But before I wanted to share this with you; I’m proud of what you guys did this year, I wish I would’ve known about this movement before so I could have been a part of it, but from what I’ve seen on your Facebook page the work done was excellent. God bless you! And hopefully one day, this country will understand that you guys are their future.! :)

December 18, 2010 will go down in history as a day we will never forget. Once again our dreams were put on hold. The Dream Act did not pass in the Senate by five votes. However, fifty-five Senators did consider our dreams worthy of a ”yes” vote. I want to thank all fifty-five of you for your support, America needs leaders like you. Change takes courage and it also means taking a chance and all of you took that first step.
I won’t even bother acknowledging the forty-one Dream killing- cowards that voted “no” and the four that didn’t even bother voting at all.

To all my fellow Dreamers out there who feel like giving up..
Those who feel being undocumented is too much for one person to handle…
To the Dreamers out there that can’t stop thinking about those forty-one “no” votes…

I’ll give you forty-one reasons why you should continue fighting.
1. In 2010 Dreamers from all over the country “came out” as Undocumented.
2. We have starved for our dreams.
3. Who would of thought Dreamers would walk to D.C. from their home state?
4. Acts of civil disobedience have taken place because of what we believe in.
5. No one believed the Dream Act would come up for a vote as a stand alone bill and it did.
6. Even Harry Potter is on our side.
7. Every great movement had its ups and downs before gaining victory.
8. We have to fight SB 1070
9. …Secure communities
10. and 287g
11. Did Martin Luther King Jr. give up on his dreams?
12. Our parents have sacrificed so much for us.
13. Giving up on our dreams is like giving up on their dreams too.
14. Their strength and bravery give us courage to keep moving forward.
15. We left our countries for a reason.
16. We’ve come this far already.
17. We can’t put our lives on hold for these politicians.
18. Politicians are scared of us Dreamers that’s why they’re trying to keep us oppressed.
19. They want use to give up; we can’t give them that pleasure.
20. We’ve got to prove the non-believers and anti-immigrants wrong.
21. We need to get our voices heard because no one else should speak for us.
22. A Dreamer out there needs your strength.
23. A Dreamer out there has lost faith.
24. Life is a struggle and there will always be a battle to face.
25. Therefore we can’t lose the momentum now.
26. If any of you have younger siblings, we are their role models.
27. We need every single Dreamer and Ally to help make change happen.
28. No body said living undocumented was going to be easy.
29. Giving up isn’t going to change our immigration status.
30. We, the NYSYLC, are here to make life a bit easier.
31. Just because the Dream Act didn’t pass this time doesn’t mean we lost.
32. It’s up to us to keep the D.R.E.A.M alive.
33. Sitting around on our butts letting our life pass us by won’t change anything.
34. We have to pave the way for the next undocumented youth.
35. Each Dreamer is worthy of being acknowledged.
36. Your dreams are worthy of acknowledgment too.
37. YOU ARE BRAVE just by facing each day as an undocumented immigrant.
38. You are part of a very important civil rights movement.
39. Our life and a better future depend on us.
40. The fight has just begun..
41. ..and we are unafraid!

“Every great dream begins with a dreamer. Always remember, you have within you the strength, the patience and the passion to reach for the stars to change the world.”
-Harriet Tubman

for dreamers

stories, questions or worries

Since the Dream Act didn’t pass in the Senate I’m sure that you all are feeling lots of different emotions. Once again I urge you to email me with any questions or concerns. This is a space to vent out any feelings you have bottled up inside. Whatever you write is up to you and you will not be judged. Your stories and worries matter! You are not alone. Remember, the insecurities and fears you have, someone else is them having too! Don’t be afraid to speak out!

If you are a fan of the Ask Angy posts..

The views expressed by the author on this post do not necessarily reflect the views of the New York State Youth Leadership Council (NYSYLC).

Older posts «